![]() |
| Monks Mound, in the background , is the largest earthen-work structure north of Mexico. From the top of it, one can see Downtown St. Louis 20 miles away. |
This is a topic that has been on my mind for some time. In fact, this topic and a great portion of this post has been saved as a draft since February of 2010. I ruminated over the use of the word primitive in some books I read on Cahokia Mounds. Cahokia Mounds is a state park located just east of St. Louis, Missouri, across the river inside Illinois. Around the year 1050 C.E., Cahokia exploded, and deeply influenced life in the Mississippi River Basin for 150 years, some(including myself) argue the influence lasted for several centuries. The influence of the enormous city can bee seen everywhere along the Mississippi River Basin from Minnesota to Louisiana.
I believe the word "primitive" tells us more abut ourselves than anything. My insights reflect no study. I am merely trying to create an argument in support of my research. I wish to share my thoughts.
My research focuses on the fact that American Indians have gone through a long and difficult process of Western colonization. While there have been some quite positive era's in American Indian History, too much as been destructive and deadly. There is a current movement within Native communities and rapidly growing outside of those communities called "decolonization." This movement seeks to limit the influence of non-native culture and traditions on the lives of Native peoples in the modern world. One aim of this movement is to revitalize traditional life-ways such as culture, history, language, and spirituality. Part of this movement is to recognize the many ways in which western European colonization harmed Native people in the U.S.
One of the factors which makes colonization possible is the view that those colonized are somehow inferior. To make such a judgment places the colonizer (the U.S. and it predecessors) in a position to rationalize their superiority by assuming the inferiority of another. Often times, I believe this to be based on the reliance of those labeled "primitive" or "inferior" technologies such as stone tools, government systems which do not meet western-style of procedure, wearing non-western clothing, non-Christian beliefs, etc.
I believe "primitive" is an aide in the process of colonization. It is the primary argument used by western societies in describing non-western or historical peoples This idea rationalizes the harsh treatment of these peoples for the purposes of bringing them "civilization." One example of this is the late 19th and early 20th century Boarding Schools. Indigenous youth were forced to attend these institutions which made practicing any form of the culture, be it language, dress, or spirituality, against the rules. As the pioneer of this forced process of assimilation once said, the purpose is to "kill the Indian and save the man"
So, how does the use of the word "primitive" tell us something of ourselves? It is a way in which we rationalize looking down on people because their ways aren't the same as ours. Native people survived and created monstrous cities, some of which were larger than their European contemporaries. They developed systems of governance utilized today in our U.S. Constitution. They developed technologies such as the bow and arrow and metallurgy independently of western society.
The word "primitive" should be used a little as possible because it shows the ultimate bias. It demonstrates the idea that the words user is some how better suited for survival. That's an opinion we should all be ashamed for.

